Just for fun · Weekend side project

Your friend told you a stock went from S$2 to S$3

“Buy this stock, it went from S$2 to S$3.” It sounds like a deal, but broker fees, dividends and free shares can change the real picture. To see what investors actually gained, I tested S$10,000 investments in 11 SGX stocks from 2 Jan 2020 to 7 Oct 2026, accounting for all these factors.

See the experimentTan Zhi Wei, PropNex Associate Group DirectorBy Zhi Wei and team · 5 min read

S$237,766

Shares worth after selling

From S$110,000 put in

S$38,677

Dividends collected

Kept as cash, not reinvested

14.6%

Yearly growth, all 11

With dividends. Price alone gives 12.1%

4.3% to 21.7%

Range across stocks

Venture lowest, DBS highest

01

Why I did this

I trained in accounting before property. Clients still ask me the same thing: if I had put money into well-known Singapore shares a few years ago, what would I have today? I wanted to give you an honest answer.

So I put S$10,000 into each of 11 SGX stocks at the 2 Jan 2020 close. Whole shares only, with fees to buy and sell. Then I valued them at the 7 Oct 2026 close, 2,470 days or 6.76 years later.

02

Why the price on the screen only tells you half

Most of us look at today's price, compare it with what we paid and call it a day. I do it too. The catch is that this misses fees, dividends and hand-outs. DBS gave 1 free share for every 10 in April 2024. Sembcorp Industries and Keppel handed out other shares and units. After a hand-out the price drops, so the chart makes your result look smaller than it really was.

Table 1The price you see versus what you really got, per year
Stock Price you see With dividends
DBS 17.5% 21.7%
Sembcorp Industries 14.9% 19.7%
Keppel 7.4% 13.3%
Venture 0.2% 4.3%

Codes shown are SGX stock codes. Prices as embedded in the tool.

S$16.48 to S$16.67

Venture price, 6.76 years

S$3,236.75

Venture dividends collected

03

How I worked out the numbers

  1. BuyI put S$10,000 into each stock and bought whole shares after fees.
  2. HoldI recorded every dividend paid and counted DBS's bonus shares from April 2024.
  3. Handle hand-outsI valued other shares or units on the day they came in, took off selling fees and treated the rest as cash.
  4. SellI valued the shares at the 7 Oct 2026 close, after selling fees.
  5. CompareI worked out net profit, dividends and yearly growth for each stock and for all 11 together.

Broker fees on each trade

Fees = [max(S$10, 0.12% × trade value) + 0.04% × trade value] × (1 + GST rate)

I kept dividends as plain cash and did not reinvest them. Fees across the 11 stocks came to S$589.04 in total: S$187.94 to buy and S$401.10 to sell.

04

What I found across the 11 stocks

S$237,766

Shares worth after selling

S$38,677

Dividends collected

14.6%

Yearly growth with dividends

Chart 1Yearly growth, price only and with dividends
Price onlyWith dividends
0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0%DBS DBS: 19.0% 19.0% DBS: 21.7% 21.7%Sembcorp Industries Sembcorp Industries: 17.4% 17.4% Sembcorp Industries: 19.7% 19.7%OCBC OCBC: 16.1% 16.1% OCBC: 18.8% 18.8%ST Engineering ST Engineering: 16.1% 16.1% ST Engineering: 17.9% 17.9%Sheng Siong Sheng Siong: 14.5% 14.5% Sheng Siong: 16.7% 16.7%SGX SGX: 13.8% 13.8% SGX: 15.5% 15.5%Keppel Keppel: 11.0% 11.0% Keppel: 13.3% 13.3%UOB UOB: 7.0% 7.0% UOB: 10.6% 10.6%Golden Agri Golden Agri: 4.2% 4.2% Golden Agri: 7.2% 7.2%Singtel Singtel: 3.5% 3.5% Singtel: 6.4% 6.4%Venture Venture: 0.1% 0.1% Venture: 4.3% 4.3%

Dividends counted as cash, not reinvested.

The results were far apart. DBS grew 21.7% a year and Venture 4.3%. The three banks got a lift from rising interest rates from 2022. If I had picked a different start date, the ranking could look very different.

05

The part we all forget: dividends

This surprised me. Dividends made up S$38,677 of the S$166,444 total gain, about 23%. For the slower stocks they mattered even more: about 98% of Venture's gain, 50% of Singtel's and 46% of Golden Agri's.

Chart 2Where each S$10,000 ended up
Shares worth after sellingDividends collected
S$0 S$10k S$20k S$30k S$40k DBS: S$32k DBS: S$5.3k DBS Sembcorp Industries: S$30k Sembcorp Industries: S$4.1k SembcorpIndustries OCBC: S$27k OCBC: S$4.6k OCBC ST Engineering: S$27k ST Engineering: S$3.0k STEngineering Sheng Siong: S$25k Sheng Siong: S$3.5k Sheng Siong SGX: S$24k SGX: S$2.5k SGX Keppel: S$20k Keppel: S$3.0k Keppel UOB: S$16k UOB: S$3.9k UOB Golden Agri: S$13k Golden Agri: S$2.8k Golden Agri Singtel: S$13k Singtel: S$2.6k Singtel Venture: S$10k Venture: S$3.2k Venture

End value on 7 Oct 2026.

Chart 3Dividends received per year
S$3.0k S$4.0k S$5.0k S$6.0k S$7.0k S$8.0k2020202120222023202420252026 2020: S$3.7k 2021: S$4.0k 2022: S$5.3k 2023: S$5.7k 2024: S$5.9k 2025: S$7.3k 2026: S$6.8k S$6.8k

2026 runs only to 7 Oct 2026.

The yearly payout almost doubled, from S$3,706 in 2020 to S$7,274 in 2025.

06

So how does this compare with property?

I am not saying one beats the other. The biggest difference is borrowing. Here every dollar came from S$110,000 of your own cash. Most property buyers take a loan. A loan makes gains and losses bigger, and you still have to repay it.

Table 2How each one puts your money to work
Item SGX shares Property
Cost to get in About 0.17% About 2.5% stamp duty on S$1m
Borrowing None in this test Loan usually funds most
Income Dividends, S$38,677 Rent, less tax and upkeep
Selling Any number of shares, same day Whole unit, weeks or months

Property figures are an illustration, not a forecast.

Return on your own cash

Return on cash = (end value − amount owed − all costs paid − cash put in + income received) ÷ cash put in

07

How I checked my own work

  • I recomputed all 11 stocks. The figures matched to the cent, apart from one 2 cent gap.
  • Fee rates and the GST steps of 7%, 8% and 9% match published SGX and IRAS rates.
  • The bank dividend yields check out: DBS 4.1%, OCBC 3.5% and UOB 3.7%.
  • I could not confirm prices or dividends after mid-2026 on my own.

Key takeaways

  • S$110,000 became S$237,766 in shares, plus S$38,677 in dividends, by 7 Oct 2026.
  • That works out to 14.6% a year with dividends, and 12.1% if you only look at the price.
  • Venture grew 4.3% a year and DBS 21.7%, so which stock you held made a big difference.
  • Dividends were about 23% of the total gain, and nearly all of Venture's.

Try it on your own numbers

SGX Experiment

See the experiment

What the tool does not do

  • I kept dividends as idle cash and only stored start and end prices, so you will not see the worst fall along the way.
  • All 11 are large companies still listed today. That can make the results look better than a random pick.
  • I used one broker rate of 0.12% with a S$10 minimum. Yours may be different.

FAQs

What dates did you test?

I bought at the 2 Jan 2020 close and valued the shares at the 7 Oct 2026 close. That is 2,470 days, or 6.76 years.

Did you reinvest the dividends?

No. I added them as cash, and they earn nothing after they are paid. They total S$38,677 and are included in the yearly growth figure.

Which fees did you count?

A 0.12% commission with a S$10 minimum, SGX's 0.04% fees, and GST at 7% in 2020 and 9% in 2026. Fees came to S$187.94 to buy and S$401.10 to sell.

So should I buy these stocks?

I am not recommending any of them. This is my look back at what happened, shared for fun. Past results cannot tell you what comes next, and nothing here is investment advice.

Sources (6)
  • IRAS: GST rate change for consumers
  • IRAS: Dividends, what is taxable and what is not
  • IRAS: Buying or acquiring property, stamp duty
  • MOF: Buyer's Stamp Duty rates raised for higher-value properties
  • OCBC: Investment fees and charges (SGX clearing and access fees)
  • SGX Group

For education and illustration only. Figures depend on the inputs and the rules in force at the time of writing, and property values can fall as well as rise. This is not financial advice.

Got a result you are not sure about?

A tool is a good start, but it cannot see your loan limits, your timeline or what similar homes nearby have sold for. Send Zhi Wei your numbers and he will take a look.

WhatsApp Zhi Wei